Talk:Gene pool
Discussion page of Gene pool
More actions
Talk
Discussion for: Gene pool • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Page scope
Gene pool covers the gene pool as a concept in two senses: the alleles of a population whose members interbreed, and a cultivated plant together with the relatives that can pass genes to it, ranked in the primary, secondary and tertiary gene pools of Harlan and de Wet (1971). It applies both senses to cannabis. How the cannabis gene pool divides into hemp, drug and regional groups belongs to Phylogenetics of Cannabis and Genetic diversity; the loss of variation from collections and landraces to Genetic erosion and Genetic contamination. The broad gene-pool groupings used to classify growing regions and other places are explained at Help:Geographic pages.
Data verification
Record source conflicts, dating problems and sources not used here. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
Sources
- Harlan and de Wet (1971), Taxon 20: 509–517: the scheme of primary, secondary and tertiary gene pools, proposed because formal taxonomy suited cultivated plants poorly, and the informal grouping of cultivars into races and subraces.
- Engels and Thormann (2020), Plants 9: 968: the three gene pools defined by ease of crossing, the division of the primary pool into cultivated and wild or weedy forms, and the taxon groups that Maxted and colleagues (2006) proposed for crops without crossing data.
- Felsenstein, Theoretical Evolutionary Genetics (text of December 2019), pp. 25 and 178: the gene pool as the collection of a population's gene frequencies, which holds under linkage equilibrium and random mating, and migration as gene flow; chapters II to VII on selection, mutation, migration, inbreeding and drift.
- National Human Genome Research Institute, Talking Glossary of Genomic and Genetic Terms, "Gene Pool": the definition, and the effect of inbreeding on the size of a gene pool.
- McPartland and Small (2020), PhytoKeys 144: 81–112: the interfertility of all cannabis populations, the dispersal of pollen, the wild-growing varieties himalayensis and asperrima, the reversion of escaped plants to a wild type and crossbreeding outside the centres of diversity.
- Welling and colleagues (2016), Frontiers in Plant Science 7: 1113: the make-up of the present gene pool, outbreeding and hybridisation, diversity in East Asia, and the effect of drug control on collections of genetic resources.
- Ren and colleagues (2021), Science Advances 7: eabg2286: whole genomes of 110 accessions, the four groups, the ancestral gene pool and the wild-growing plants sampled.
Source discrepancies
- Wild relatives or escapes. McPartland and Small treat two wild-growing varieties of South and Central Asia, himalayensis and asperrima, as the wild relatives of the drug domesticates, while noting that truly wild plants are hard to tell from plants that have reverted to a wild type. Ren and colleagues found every wild-growing plant in their sample, including plants from south of the Himalayas and from Central Asia, to be a historical escape from cultivation.
- How many species. Welling and colleagues follow Small and Cronquist (1976) in treating Cannabis as a single species; other treatments recognise more. The question is set out at Cannabis taxonomy.
Terms
- GP1a and GP1b are the cultivated and the wild or weedy forms of a crop within its primary gene pool; GP2 and GP3 are the secondary and tertiary gene pools. TG1a to TG4 are the taxon groups of Maxted and colleagues.
- Feral plants grow outside cultivation but descend from crops; wild plants descend from populations that were never cultivated.
Images reserved in the article
One image has a place in the article but is not yet uploaded:
File:Cannabis-gene-pool-tiers-diagram.jpg(lead), a diagram to be drawn: a central disc labelled "GP1a: cultivated forms of the crop", a ring around it labelled "GP1b: wild or weedy forms of the crop", a second ring labelled "GP2: secondary gene pool: genes moved by conventional breeding, with difficulty" and an outer ring labelled "GP3: tertiary gene pool: genes moved only by embryo rescue, somatic fusion or genetic engineering". The rings carry no crop or taxon names.