Talk:ZOM-IND-HIM-0920220005

Talk

Discussion for: ZOM-IND-HIM-0920220005 • View • Links • Related changes

Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.

Page scope

ZOM-IND-HIM-0920220005 is about a single collection of cannabis, a seed lot or a herbarium specimen: where and when it was gathered, by whom, and what the sources say about the plants.

Data verification

Check the main page for documentation tier status. Discuss coordinate accuracy, photo quality, or collection details here.

Discussion

Source discrepancies

• Collection year. collection_date read "05/09/2023" from the page's creation on 14 March 2026 (batch "Chanderkhani Valley", filled from the Zomia inventory). Every other dated statement gives 2022: the accession name and sample_harvest_date; the product page ("Sourcing: Eloise (2022)"; "sourced directly from the 2022 harvest"); and the collector's diary, whose posts carry the publication dates 1 September 2022 (India 2022 Himachal Pradesh Collection Trip), 2 September (Chandigarh: "continuing on tomorrow to Kullu-Manali"), 4 September (Naggar-Rumsu), 5 September (Rumsu Feral Landrace), 6 September (the two Upper Field posts) and 7 September 2022 (Naggar to Parvati), as the posts' own metadata gave them on 28 September 2026. The Zomia register, as it stood on 17 September 2026, held 2022-09-04 for this accession, one day earlier than the inventory's 05/09; the page keeps the inventory's day. The field now reads 2022-09-05 (the stored 2023 is a data-entry error), in the form Property:Has collection date documents, so SMW no longer reads the day as the month. The day is the inventory's; the diary's first post from Rumsu is dated 4 September, and neither is adjusted to the other.
• Name forms. The inventory's descriptive_name "Pulag General Population 2022" (the infobox and, since this correction, the lead); the page's original lead "Chanderkhani Valley 'Pulag' General Population 2022", unchanged from 14 March 2026 until this correction; the product page's lot name "Pulag General Population 2022".
• Type and collector labels. The product page types the lot "General population, domesticate landrace" and notes "Collected from plants throughout the valley by locals making charas in Rumsu"; the accession stores classification = Landrace, accession_type = General population and collector = Éloïse. The article states both. The lot note names Rumsu although the lot, like the accession, is Pulag's; the article quotes the note as printed.
• Harvest window and height. Accession: September to December; 1.5 to 3.0 m. Product page, for the appellation: "Regional Harvest: October to November"; "Height: 1.5-7 metres". The article states both.
• Elevation. Accession: 2,200 m at 32.106022, 77.198350. Product page: "Pulag - North Facing (2500m)"; lot altitude "2200-2300m". Éloise 17:12, 28 September 2026 (+07)

Georeferencing

• The stored point 32.106022, 77.198350 is the collector's. SRTM 30 m gives 2,243 m there and ASTER GDEM 2,245 m, against the recorded 2,200 m, a difference of 43 m. Éloise 17:12, 28 September 2026 (+07)

Editorial treatment

• Cultivation system. Semi-Feral is entered as Semi-feral, the spelling the property allows (conformed 17 September 2026). The value was Semi-feral until 1 May 2026. The property rejected Semi-Feral, so only Intercropped had been stored. Éloise 01:49, 18 September 2026 (+07)
• Tehsil. admin_3 read "Naggar Tehsil" from the page's creation. The district administration's list of tehsils and sub-tehsils has no Naggar (Kullu, Bhuntar, Manali, Banjar, Anni, Sainj and Nirmand, with the sub-tehsils Jari and Nither; hpkullu.nic.in, read 27 September 2026); the 2011 Census sub-districts of Kullu district are Kullu, Manali, Banjar, Sainj, Ani and Nermand, and the census village directory puts Up Muhal Pulag (012741) in Kullu sub-district and the Naggar community development block. The field now reads Kullu Tehsil, the form the district's other accessions use for their tehsil ("Bhuntar Tehsil"); admin_4 = Naggar Block stands. The product page's own label for the place is "District: Naggar".
• Lead sentence conformed to descriptive_name, the inventory-synced field, which the sync rewrote on 14 and 15 March and 28 and 29 April 2026 while the lead kept the batch-creation form.
• Inventory. The page is synced from the Zomia inventory; a sync run before the inventory row carries the same values (date collected 2022-09-05; subdivision 3 Kullu Tehsil) would write the old values back.
• Month-first storage. The other ZOM accessions' dd/mm/yyyy dates are still stored month-first, pending a template-side fix. This page's ISO value does not depend on it. Éloise 17:12, 28 September 2026 (+07)