Talk:Willem Gerbrand Boorsma
More actions
Discussion for: Willem Gerbrand Boorsma • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
Place of death
The Cyclopaedia of Malesian Collectors gives Oegstgeest. The Leiden death register for 1937 (akte 260) enters the death at Leiden on 12 March 1937, with Oegstgeest as his place of residence; the death is also entered in the Oegstgeest register. The article follows the Leiden register. De Nederlandsche ridderorden (1937) lists him at Oegstgeest.
Directorship of the agricultural school
The Cyclopaedia of Malesian Collectors has him director of the School of Agriculture at Buitenzorg from 1914; De Nederlandsche ridderorden (1937, p. 355) dates his directorship of the Middelbare Landbouwschool to 1913. The same entry dates his honourable discharge from government service to 1924.
The yearbook report and the Teysmannia article
The survey report in the yearbook for 1915 (section F, pp. 21–29, printed by the Landsdrukkerij in 1917) and the 1918 article are one text, lightly reworked. Only the yearbook has the sentence that the herbarium material from Aceh had been identified as Cannabis indica (p. 23). A listing of the yearbook report as a Jaarverslag for 1915 describes the same document under another title and year; the volume is the Jaarboek.
Chemistry
The 1892 article's closing paragraph names choline, "cannabine" and "cannabinon" as the constituents the European literature of the time credited with the drug's action (p. 799); it reports no analysis by Boorsma and no material from the archipelago. The 1918 survey's own examination of the cannabis it received was to smoke it and to look for resin on the female tops (pp. 329–330). The statement in Indonesia that Boorsma's analyses of the 1890s and 1910s identified cannabine, cannabinon and choline in samples from Sumatra and Java has no support in either text.
Extent of use and cultivation in Aceh
The Transnational Institute's briefing (2016, pp. 4–5) says that the study found widespread consumption largely limited to Aceh and East and West Sumatra. Boorsma's conclusion (1918, p. 331) treats the West Coast, the East Coast and Aceh together: hemp grown "hoewel niet in belangrijke mate" and used "in hoofdzaak door vreemdelingen, zeer weinig door de inheemsche bevolking". For Aceh the returns report the plant in most divisions with plantings in a few (p. 329) and use described as slight (p. 327). The Aceh return describes seedlings raised from seed and transplanted (p. 329); neither printing describes seed kept over generations or cannabis grown among other crops.
The list of places where the plant was unknown
The list (1918, p. 325; 1915 report, p. 21) is the Opiumregie's, compiled from residency returns. On Java it names Bantam and Rembang only. For the rest of Java the survey's finding is that most plants sent in under gendji and similar names were not cannabis, which concerns the names and the material sent, not the presence or absence of the plant. Outside Java the list names South New Guinea among the residencies; the report of the Archbold expedition (1942, pp. 201, 208, 211) shows parts of the island's interior, including the populous Grand Valley of the Baliem, still unknown to outsiders in 1938. A description of the survey as finding cannabis absent from New Guinea or from most of Java goes further than the list.
Images reserved in the article
One image has a place in the article but is not yet uploaded:
File:Willem-Gerbrand-Boorsma-portrait.jpg(infobox): a portrait of Boorsma. The portrait printed in De Nederlandsche ridderorden, 1900–1936 (1937, p. 355), anonymous and in the public domain, is on Wikimedia Commons asFile:Willem Gebrand Boorsma.jpg, but only at 187 × 234 pixels. The Cyclopaedia of Malesian Collectors lists another portrait, plate 8 of Annales du Jardin botanique de Buitenzorg 45 (1935).