Talk:Pleiotropy
Discussion page of Pleiotropy
More actions
Talk
Discussion for: Pleiotropy • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Page scope
Pleiotropy covers one locus acting on several traits: how it is told apart from close linkage, direct effects and chains, what is counted as a trait, its bearing on selection and fitness, and what cannabis mapping has measured. The characters themselves belong to Genetic traits, variance components to Heritability, mapping methods to Quantitative trait locus, interaction between loci to Epistasis, the statistic to Genetic correlation, the breeder's equation to Response to selection and trade-offs between sites to Local adaptation.
Data verification
Record source conflicts, figures that differ between studies and sources not used here. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
Sources
- Stearns (2010), Genetics: the history of the word and the concept, Mendel's third character, Grüneberg, Hadorn, Williams, the molecular mechanisms, universal and modular pleiotropy. A corrigendum of 2011 concerns only Hadorn's nationality.
- Paaby and Rockman (2013), Trends in Genetics: the three meanings, trait counting, the QTL surveys, power, the linkage question, selection tests.
- Solovieff and colleagues (2013), Nature Reviews Genetics: biological, mediated and spurious pleiotropy, with examples from human disease.
- Wang and colleagues (2010), PNAS; Hill and Zhang (2012), Genetics; Orr (2000), Evolution: how many traits a gene affects, and what that means for adaptation.
- Chen and Lübberstedt (2010), Trends in Plant Science; Jiang and Zeng (1995), Genetics; Lande (1980), Genetics: trait correlations, the test against close linkage, and the model of genetic covariance.
- Latta and Gardner (2009), Evolution; Anderson and colleagues (2011), Trends in Genetics; Ågren and colleagues (2013), PNAS: fitness in wild oat and in plant adaptation generally.
- Hellens and colleagues (2010), PLoS ONE; Xue and colleagues (2008) and Soyk and colleagues (2017), Nature Genetics; Bomblies and Doebley (2006), Genetics: genes in pea, rice, tomato and maize.
- Salentijn and colleagues (2019), Frontiers in Plant Science: flowering and other traits in soybean and other crops, and candidate genes for hemp. Its soybean lines are those of Cober and Morrison (2010).
- Woods and colleagues (2021), Genetics; Manansala-Siazon and colleagues (2025), Plants; Babaei and Torkamaneh (2026), The Plant Genome; Babaei and colleagues (2026), Scientific Reports; Toth and colleagues (2022), Frontiers in Plant Science; Petit and colleagues (2020), Frontiers in Genetics; Pancaldi and colleagues (2025), Journal of Experimental Botany; Aardema and DeSalle (2021), PLOS ONE: cannabis.
Where the sources disagree
- Agronomic and biochemical traits in cannabis. Woods and colleagues found no shared positions and no significant correlation between the two classes in one cross of two hemp cultivars. Babaei and Torkamaneh report one marker, Cs1 in CsFTL3, associated with biomass and with cannabidivarin in a panel of Iranian landraces. The materials differ, and Woods and colleagues could not then say whether their result was specific to the population. Babaei and Torkamaneh's discussion also names CsCFL1 among the loci reaching cannabinoid profiles, while their tables list no cannabinoid trait for its marker Cs2. The table on the article follows the tables.
- Seed size and plant size. Thousand-seed mass shared clusters with plant size in Carmagnola × USO31. Manansala-Siazon and colleagues found no significant correlation and no shared QTLs in their cross, and take this to mean that small plants with large seeds can be bred. They note that the parents, the sex system and the growing conditions of the two crosses differ.
- Universal pleiotropy. Stearns treats Wright as an explicit advocate and Fisher as an implicit one. Paaby and Rockman hold that Wright qualified the idea with "nearly" and "almost", and that Fisher's model concerns axes of selection and makes no claim about measurable traits.
- How much pleiotropy there is. Wang and colleagues conclude that pleiotropy is low and modular. Hill and Zhang show that such patterns can arise from models with effects on all traits at all loci. Paaby and Rockman's view is that the deletion and QTL data measure different things, and that low power may explain why both give the same shape.
- Mendel's third character. Stearns writes that whether the three features come from one gene is unknown. Hellens and colleagues, in the same year, identify the gene A and treat the seed coat as part of the phenotype of a mutants, while their tests concern flower pigment.
- The word "spurious". Grüneberg's spurious pleiotropy is a real effect of one product on several traits. In Solovieff and colleagues the word means an association that is false, so the two usages should not be merged.
- Number of traits in Babaei and Torkamaneh. Their methods give 42 traits and their results 40 with significant associations.
How far the evidence goes
- Neither Woods and colleagues nor Babaei and Torkamaneh report a test of pleiotropy against close linkage. Woods and colleagues work from overlapping confidence intervals of QTLs, and Babaei and Torkamaneh from association at markers. The block of 3 kilobases at CsFTL3 is narrow, and three different markers in it carry the traits.
- Woods and colleagues' two candidates have different standing. The olivetol synthase result rests on a yeast assay and concerns cannabinoids. TINY is a hypothesis from sequence homology and one amino-acid change.
- The Iranian figures come from 145 samples pooled by sex and block, grown in one greenhouse complex at Mashhad, with trait values averaged across each pool. Each percentage is the variance explained by one marker. The minor allele frequencies are low: 5 per cent at Cs2, 8 at Cs5, 9 at Cs1 and 11 at Cs13. The genotype classes compared on the article are therefore uneven in size. The paper compares CC with AA for height and flowering at Cs2, and CC with AC for its biomass figures, which the article leaves out.
- Cannabidivarin at Cs1 is a large share of the variance in a trait with a low absolute value, 0.0097 against 0.0012 per cent by weight.
- Babaei and Torkamaneh define nodes on the main stem as nodes on and below the main inflorescence, and total weights as the sum of the weights of stem, leaf and flower. Several of the traits counted for one marker are therefore not independent. The paper counts them as distinct.
- Toth and colleagues report the effect of Autoflower1 on flowering date, height and wet biomass in 96 plants of one family and do not call it pleiotropy. Their own account of early flowering leaves open a chain from flowering to size. The figures are from one field trial in 2021.
- Aardema and DeSalle take their phenotypes from public websites, which describe named strains, and their stated aim is to test the use of such data for association studies. They call the shared variants possible pleiotropic effects.
- García-de Heer and colleagues (2024) name possible negative pleiotropic effects of male monoecy on agronomic performance as a matter for further study. They report no measurement of them.
- Candidate genes in Salentijn and colleagues are drawn from other crops, and its statements on hemp concern what may be expected of those genes.
- The results on fitness and antagonistic pleiotropy on the article come from wild oat and Arabidopsis. The crop examples come from pea, rice, tomato, soybean and maize. None of them is a result in cannabis.
Terms
- QTL: a position on the genome statistically associated with variation in a measured trait.
- Linkage group: a set of markers mapped together; in Woods and colleagues these correspond to the ten chromosomes.
- Haploblock: a run of markers in strong linkage disequilibrium, here r2 of at least 0.75.
- Conditional neutrality: an allele with a fitness effect in one environment and none in another.
- Isogenic lines: lines that differ at one locus or a few on an otherwise shared background.
Images reserved in the article
One image has a place in the article but is not yet uploaded:
File:Pleiotropy-direct-chain-and-linked-loci.jpg(One locus or two close together), a diagram to be drawn: one locus acting on two traits, one locus acting on the second trait through the first, and two loci close together each acting on one trait.