Talk:Carl Linnaeus
More actions
Discussion for: Carl Linnaeus • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
Date of birth
The Svenskt biografiskt lexikon gives 13 May 1707, at Stenbrohult. Many other works give 23 May 1707. The article follows the lexicon.
Editions of the dissertations
Sponsalia plantarum (1746), Inebriantia (1762) and the prize essay Disquisitio de sexu plantarum (1760) are cited from the reprints in Amoenitates Academicae edited by J. C. D. Schreber at Erlangen: volume 1 in its third edition (1787), volume 6 in its second edition (1789) and volume 10 (1790). Page numbers are those of these reprints. The first printings, and James Edward Smith's English translation of the prize essay (1786), were not consulted. The two dissertations were defended under Linnaeus's presidency by the students named on their title pages (J. G. Wahlbom and O. R. Alander), and the article attributes their statements to the dissertations.
Class and order of hemp
The Hortus Cliffortianus (p. 457) and the fifth edition of the Genera Plantarum (1754) place Cannabis in Dioecia Pentandria. In the copy of Species Plantarum consulted, the running heads of pages 1026 and 1027 read "Dioecia Tetrandria", so the article names only the class for 1753.
Date of the Hortus Cliffortianus
The preface is dated at Hartekamp on 30 July 1737 and the engraved frontispiece is dated 1738. Stearn (1974) dates the book 1738, and the article follows him.
Where the type came from
The protologue gives "Habitat in India". The Hortus Cliffortianus gives the East Indies, Japan and Malabar, and the Materia Medica Japan and the East Indies. Stearn (1974) read the locality as resting on Rheede's plates and the description as based on hemp cultivated in northern Europe. Schultes and his co-authors (1974) report "Persia" added in Linnaeus's annotated copy. McPartland and Small (2020, supplementary material 1) place the type specimen in northern Europe, likely Uppsala.
Was Herb. Linn. 1177.2 in the herbarium in 1753?
Stearn (1974) took the number "1" on the sheet, which matches the species number in the first edition of Species Plantarum, as evidence that Linnaeus had it in 1753 or soon after. Schultes and his co-authors (1974) held that neither Linnaean sheet was in the herbarium in 1753. The Typification Project accepts Villiers's 1973 designation of 1177.2 as lectotype and notes that Stearn agreed the plant was in Linnaeus's possession in 1753.