Jump to content
Toggle menu
Toggle preferences menu
Toggle personal menu
Not logged in
Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits.

Talk:Cannabis in Sufism

Discussion page of Cannabis in Sufism
Talk

Discussion for: Cannabis in Sufism • View • Links • Related changes

Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.

Page scope
The page covers hemp, above all hashish, among Sufis and wandering dervishes: the 13th-century Qalandars and Haydaris, the legends crediting a Sufi master with discovering the drug, the devotional names and claims attached to it, the opposition of Sufis and jurists, the Abdals of Rum, dervishes in Iran, malangs, faqirs and shrines in South Asia and Afghanistan, the Moroccan brotherhoods, and how hostile witnesses and later scholars have framed the subject. Sufism in general is covered on Sufism, verse on Sufi poetry, and the regional practice in more detail on Cannabis in Afghan culture, Fakirs in Bengali culture and Cannabis in Riffian culture.
Data verification
Record source conflicts, dating problems and unresolved readings here. Keep narrative content on the article.

Discussion

Who told the Haydar story

  • Karamustafa (1994, pp. 56–57 and p. 120 n. 30) has al-ʿUkbarī hear the story at Tustar in 658/1260 from Jaʿfar ibn Muḥammad al-Shīrāzī, whom he calls a Qalandari shaykh. In Silvestre de Sacy's translation of al-Maqrīzī (1806, pp. 120–123) the story is told in 658/1259–60 by a monk of Shaykh Haydar's order. Neither account shows whether these are one informant described in two ways.
  • Al-Zarkashī's date for the discovery, about 550/1155–56 (Karamustafa, p. 120 n. 30), falls well before Haydar's death, which al-Maqrīzī puts in 618/1221–22 and Yazici (2000) gives as 1216, 1221 or 1231.

Hashish or opium among the Abdals of Rum

  • Karamustafa (1994, pp. 71–72, 75), working from Vahidi, Menavino and the poet Hayretî, describes the Abdals carrying hashish in a leather pouch and fond of hashish and wine. Schimmel (1975, p. 335) calls the abdalan-i Rum "notorious for their use of opium".

The opponents' words

  • The devotional names and claims that medieval Sufis are said to have attached to hashish come almost wholly from writers who condemned the practice: Ibn Ghānim al-Maqdisī, al-Qasṭallānī and Ibn Taymiyya. Lozano (1996, p. 91) holds that how far these phrases reflect the users' own beliefs cannot be known, and that al-Badrī's text is a literary piece. The one first-hand statement of purpose, al-ʿUkbarī's, concerns the drying of the semen (pp. 89–90).

Colonial witnesses

  • Ewing (1997, p. 52) reads Burton's association of hemp with fakirs as part of a colonial picture of Indian degeneracy. The commission's report (para. 435) groups fakirs with jogis, sanyasis and other ascetics, most of them devotees of Shiva; paras. 436–438 and 442 are those that concern Muslims and Muslim shrines.