Talk:Archaeological sites census

Talk

Discussion for: Archaeological sites census • View • Links • Related changes

Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.

Page scope

Archaeological sites census lists archaeological sites with a cannabis find reported in a review of the archaeological evidence, with the find, its date and the review that reports it, for the sites whose position two independent sources agree on. A site with an article of its own is not listed.

Data verification

Record source conflicts, dating problems and sources not used here. Keep narrative content on the article.

Discussion

Sources

Dal Martello et al. (2024): Karakhoja, Erdaojingzi, Daxinzhuang.
Nelson et al. (2020): Yoshinogari.
McPartland and Hegman (2018): Thayngen-Weier, Cave below Merkstein Castle, Bad Vöslau, Ehrenstein, Dănceni I, Arkaim, Sintashta, Uch-Bash, Hallstatt, Tepenec, Trakhtemyriv, Teishebaini, Myriv, Corvin tér, Budapest, Lattes, La Tène, Coll del Moro, Rostislavl, Ananyino.
Bates (2019): Alamgirpur.
McPartland, Hegman and Long (2019): Tavdinsky grotto, Shendun, Dongshancun, Chengtoushan, Lajia, Sannai Maruyama, Hemudu.

Sites not listed

Xinzhai and Longqiuzhuang are in McPartland, Hegman and Long's table with pollen coded H (hop) and no reading of it as Cannabis.

Dates

Dates in BP are years before 1950. For the map's time bar a date in BP is read as 1950 minus the figure, and a date in thousands of years (ka) the same way.
A site with no date in the review (Cave below Merkstein Castle, Bad Vöslau, Ehrenstein, Tepenec, La Tène, Alamgirpur) has no find year.

Georeferencing

Each position is the point the review prints, where a gazetteer object for the site (Wikidata, OpenStreetMap, GeoNames) lies within about 2 km of it; where the review prints no point, or prints a point more than 2 km from the site, it is the point where two independent gazetteer objects for the site agree within about 2 km. Positions are rounded to two decimals (about 1 km). A town or district point is never used for a site.

Karakhoja (42.85, 89.53). No review's printed point; Karakhoja is the Gaochang ruins, which Wikidata and OpenStreetMap place 0.6 km apart.
Erdaojingzi (42.20, 119.05). No review's printed point; Wikidata's Erdaojingzi site and OpenStreetMap's site museum, built on the excavation, lie 0.1 km apart.
Daxinzhuang (36.71, 117.11). No review's printed point; OpenStreetMap's and Wikidata's Daxinzhuang site lie 0.07 km apart, in Jinan.
Yoshinogari (33.33, 130.38). No review's printed point; OpenStreetMap's and Wikidata's Yoshinogari site lie 0.05 km apart.
Thayngen-Weier (47.74, 8.70). OpenStreetMap maps the Neolithic lakeshore settlement at Weier 50 m from the review's printed point.
Cave below Merkstein Castle, Bad Vöslau (47.98, 16.13). OpenStreetMap's Merkensteinhöhle entrance and GeoNames' Burgruine Merkenstein both lie within 0.15 km of the review's printed point.
Ehrenstein (48.41, 9.92). OpenStreetMap's Steinzeitdorf Ehrenstein and Wikidata's site item agree with the review's printed point within 0.1 km.
Dănceni I (46.96, 28.72). Wikidata's Dănceni I settlement item lies 2.0 km from the review's printed point, which is the village itself.
Arkaim (52.65, 59.57). OpenStreetMap's Arkaim fortified settlement and GeoNames' Arkhaim lie within 0.05 km of the review's printed point.
Sintashta (52.49, 60.19). OpenStreetMap's Sintashta fortified settlement lies 0.9 km from the review's printed point; Wikidata repeats the review's printed point.
Uch-Bash (44.60, 33.61). Wikidata's Uch-Bash settlement item lies 0.7 km from the review's printed point, near Inkerman.
Hallstatt (47.56, 13.64). OpenStreetMap's Gräberfeld (the Hallstatt cemetery) lies 0.7 km from the second review's printed point; the first review's printed point is 3 km away.
Tepenec (49.70, 17.36). The review's printed point is on Tepenec hill: OpenStreetMap's Tepenec locality lies 0.1 km away and Wikidata's castle ruin on the hilltop repeats the point.
Trakhtemyriv (49.98, 31.38). Wikidata's and OpenStreetMap's Trakhtemyriv hillfort lie 0.8 and 1.3 km from the review's printed point.
Teishebaini (40.15, 44.45). GeoNames, Wikidata and OpenStreetMap place Karmir Blur within 0.2 km of the review's printed point.
Myriv (48.95, 28.89). OpenStreetMap's Scythian hillfort at Nemyriv lies 0.04 km from the review's printed point; Wikidata repeats the point.
Corvin tér, Budapest (47.50, 19.04). The review's printed point lies on OpenStreetMap's Corvin tér, Budapest, the square the excavation is named for.
Lattes (43.57, 3.91). OpenStreetMap's and Wikidata's Lattara lie 0.4-0.6 km from the review's printed point.
La Tène (47.01, 7.02). GeoNames' and Wikidata's La Tène site lie 1.1-1.3 km from the review's printed point.
Coll del Moro (41.05, 0.39). OpenStreetMap's Iberian settlement of Coll del Moro lies 0.05 km from the review's printed point, in Gandesa (Tarragona), not Barcelona as the review says.
Rostislavl (54.87, 38.63). OpenStreetMap's and Wikidata's Rostislavl hillfort lie 1.0 km from the review's printed point, south-east of Moscow near Kolomna, not 70 km west as the review says.
Ananyino (55.72, 52.13). Wikidata's Ananyino burial ground and OpenStreetMap's marker for it lie 0.05 km apart, 6 km south-east of the review's printed point, which is Yelabuga town; GeoNames' Anan'ino village is 1.2 km from them.
Alamgirpur (29.00, 77.48). OpenStreetMap and Wikidata place Alamgirpur 0.3 km apart, about 6 km south-south-west of the review's printed point.
Tavdinsky grotto (51.78, 85.73). OpenStreetMap's Tavdinsky caves lie 0.01 km from the review's printed point.
Shendun (31.31, 119.23). OpenStreetMap's Shendun site lies 0.9 km from the review's printed point.
Dongshancun (31.93, 120.40). Read with latitude and longitude swapped back, the review's printed point lies 1.1 km from Wikidata's Dongshancun site.
Chengtoushan (29.69, 111.66). OpenStreetMap's Chengtoushan site lies 0.07 km from the review's printed point; Wikidata repeats the point.
Lajia (35.86, 102.81). OpenStreetMap's and Wikidata's Lajia site lie 1.2-1.3 km from the review's printed point.
Sannai Maruyama (40.81, 140.70). OpenStreetMap's and GeoNames' Sannai Maruyama lie within 0.2 km of the review's printed point.
Hemudu (29.96, 121.35). Wikidata's Hemudu site lies 0.6 km from the review's printed point.