Talk:Cooper 1104 (1914)
More actions
Discussion for: Cooper 1104 (1914) • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
Evidentiary scope
The label's remarks line reads 4' growing in swamp (four feet tall, growing in a swamp), at Chukka, above 3,000 feet, in July 1914; the catalogue gives the habitat as in swamp. The label names no use, variety or local name. The plant grew in a natural habitat, with no word of cultivation. The accession is classified Feral, by inference from the label and the catalogue; the label does not say whether the plants descended from a crop. A single gathering does not establish a continuing population, and no conservation priority is assigned.
Label reading
Read from the Edinburgh image (E00150670, 2762 × 4096 pixels).
- Printed label FLORA OF BHUTAN., with printed field names (Locality, Date, Altitude, Remarks, No.) filled in by hand, and the printed foot R. E. Cooper, Collector for A. K. Bulley, Esq., Cheshire.
- Pencil 153 above the label: a filing figure, not a field datum.
- Pencil = 153 and 5 above the label; a closed packet at the top of the sheet carries the number 1104.
- Handwritten entries. Locality Chukka. Timpu.; Date 3/7/14; Altitude 3000'+; Remarks No. 1104, 4' growing in swamp, Cannabis sativa L.
Georeferencing
The label's Chukka is read as Chukha, on the Wang Chhu, and its Timpu as Cooper's name for the wider Thimphu region; both readings are identifications made for this page. The point 27.06, 89.56 is the town of Chukha, OpenStreetMap node 6400147689, which reverse-geocodes into Chukha District, the province the page gives. SRTM puts the town at 1,470 metres. This label gives only 3000'+, above about 914 metres, and the next day's sheet from the same place, Cooper 1174 (1914), gives 4,500 feet, about 1,372 metres, within 100 metres of the town. The point places the gathering at Chukha, not at the swamp the label describes; the uncertainty allows about 2 km for the place and its approaches, and 1 km for the rounding of the point. An earlier version of this note gave no point because no settlement point for Chukha had been found, only the centroid of the district. Basis: settlement point. Uncertainty: about 3 km.
Editorial treatment
The collector field takes R.E. Cooper, the label's form, and the article uses the initials only. The catalogue gives the full name as Roland Edgar Cooper; the International Plant Names Index (author 1790-1) and the Harvard Index of Botanists give Rowland Edgar Cooper, 1890–1962. The province field takes the present-day dzongkhag in its English form, Chukha District, because the label names Chukka. The locality field keeps the label's spelling. The elevation field is empty because 3000'+ is a lower limit.
Source citations remain in the article. Éloise 04:16, 5 October 2026 (+07)