Jump to content
Toggle menu
Toggle preferences menu
Toggle personal menu
Not logged in
Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits.

Talk:West Indies ganja trade

Discussion page of West Indies ganja trade
Talk

Discussion for: West Indies ganja trade • View • Links • Related changes

Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.

Page scope
West Indies ganja trade treats the shipment of ganja from India to Trinidad and British Guiana for the Indian workers there and their descendants: the evidence that the two colonies relied on imports, the Trinidad import system of 1915 and 1928, the one quantity given in the sources, the colonial laws, and the exports of the 1930s. The migration that brought cannabis use to the Caribbean is told in Spread of cannabis to the Americas. Imports into Jamaica and Mauritius whose origin no source states are noted, not treated as part of the route.
Data verification
Record source conflicts, dating problems and sources not used here. Keep narrative content on the article.

Discussion

Sources

  • History. James H. Mills's chapter "Globalizing ganja" (2007), in the second edition of Consuming Habits, is the main source for the trade: Robert Mitchell's letter in the report of the Natal Indian Immigrants Commission (1887), the Trinidad Ganja Ordinance of 1915 as Mills reads it, and the Home Office letter of 21 November 1939, which Mills quotes from India Office file M/3/381. Some later writers cite the chapter with the spelling "Globalising" or with the first edition's year, 1995; the chapter is not in the first edition. Jamie Banks's chapter in Cannabis: Global Histories (2021) gives British Guiana's 1861 ordinance, its reliance on imports, and the Mauritius ordinances. Chris S. Duvall's The African Roots of Marijuana (2019, p. 29 and n. 119 on p. 242) gives the 1891 figure, citing an article signed "Pharmaceutical Resident", "Opium-dealing in British Guiana", Chemist and Druggist 42 (28 January 1893), pp. 120–121.
  • Trinidad. Ansley Hamid's The Ganja Complex (2002, pp. xl–xli) for the licensed import system and the importer in Port of Spain; he gives no source for these sentences. The Ganja Ordinance, 1915 (ss. 4–8) and the Dangerous Drugs Ordinance, 1928 (s. 3) are cited from their texts. The ordinances of 1885, 1894 and 1899 are cited from the descriptions in the National Archives catalogue only.
  • India. The Indian Hemp Drugs Commission's report (vol. I, ch. VII, para. 279, p. 107) for Bengal's shipments by sea in 1892–93 and the unexplained 774 maunds of 1891–92.
  • Jamaica. Vera Rubin and Lambros Comitas, Ganja in Jamaica (1975), p. 22, for the 1913 debate.
  • Not yet read. The Chemist and Druggist article of 1893, which may say where British Guiana's ganja came from; the report of the Natal Indian Immigrants Commission (1887), p. 411, for Mitchell's letter in full; the Trinidad Collector of Customs' report on ganja of 1902 (National Archives, CO 295/412); D. W. D. Comins's notes on emigration to British Guiana and to Trinidad (1893); Peter Hanoomansingh's thesis (University of the West Indies, 2010), pp. 236–238, which Banks cites for British Guiana's imports; and the Bengal Excise Administration Report for 1892–93, the Commission's source for the shipping figures.

Where the sources disagree

  • Trinidad's law in the 1880s. Mitchell's letter, printed in 1887, says that in Trinidad the import and the cultivation of ganja were both prohibited. The ordinance of 1885 imposed a licence duty on cultivation, and the catalogue describes the ordinance of 1894 as the one that prohibited cultivation, sale or keeping. Mitchell's statement is attributed to him; the dates of the ordinances are the catalogue's.
  • Who regulated the trade in Trinidad. Hamid places the import-only system in "the 1900s" without a date; the earliest ordinance cited that sets it out is that of 1915.
  • The first workers to Mauritius. Mills dates the migration from 1834 but the first workers to Mauritius to 1829, without saying why the two differ; both dates are his.

Georeferencing

A town on the route is given a point where two gazetteers, Wikidata and OpenStreetMap, put it within about 2 km of each other. Points are entered to two decimal places.

  • Port of Spain: 10.66, -61.52. Wikidata (Q39178) 10.667, -61.517; OpenStreetMap (node 2718091147, place=city) 10.657, -61.518; 1.0 km apart.

India and British Guiana (stored as Guyana) are given without a point: no source names the Indian port the ganja left from, and the British Guiana sources name the colony, not a port.

Infobox

  • Places. The origin is India: the Home Office letter of 1939 and Hamid name India, and the sources cited name no port. The destinations are Port of Spain, where the 1915 ordinance required all imported ganja to be warehoused and where Hamid places a large importer, and British Guiana, which Mitchell and Duvall name as a colony.
  • Dates. The first year is 1887, the year of the report that prints Mitchell's letter; his time as Agent General, when the imports he describes were already arriving, is not dated in the sources cited. The sources cited do not say when the shipments stopped: the last dated evidence is the Home Office letter of November 1939, so the end year is left empty, the period is given in words, and the status is "Not known".
  • Legal status. "Changed over time": dutied imports into British Guiana; in Trinidad a cultivation licence (1885), prohibition (1894), regulated sale (1899) and licensed imports (1915, 1928); and, by Mills's reading, exports from India in the 1930s that the Geneva convention of 1925 did not allow.
  • Scale. The only quantity is Duvall's 10,000 lb for British Guiana in 1891. The sources cited give no figure for Trinidad.

Open points

  • The Indian port or ports of shipment, and who carried the ganja before the 1930s.
  • Whether the 89 maunds that Bengal shipped to foreign ports in 1892–93, or the 774 maunds of 1891–92, went to the West Indies. The Commission does not say.
  • Whether Jamaica's imports of 1913 and Mauritius's imports after 1883 came from India. The sources cited do not say, so neither colony is entered as a destination.
  • When the exports to Trinidad ended.