Talk:Phenotypic plasticity
More actions
Discussion for: Phenotypic plasticity • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
Cannabinoid ratios in Naim-Feil and colleagues (2023)
The study grew clones of 119 medicinal cannabis genotypes together in a single controlled-environment facility. Its abstract says the ratios between cannabinoids "remain fairly stable" across the cultivation facility, and the results compare clones of one genotype within that facility, where, in five clones each of six genotypes, THC differed by 25 to 43 per cent and CBD by 11 to 36 per cent. The study did not grow any genotype in a second facility, so it does not show that the ratios hold from one facility, site or season to another. The statement that the ratio of THC to CBD stays constant under different environmental conditions appears in the paper's introduction and discussion as a finding of earlier studies.
Plant form at high altitude
The studies cited in the article do not compare altitudes, so they do not settle whether compact, densely flowering forms follow from growing at high altitude and in high light. Giupponi and colleagues (2020) grew clones of the hemp cultivar Kompolti at 1,200 m and 130 m and report the chemistry of the inflorescences, with no measure of plant form.
Which quantitative characters are more plastic
Petit and colleagues (2020) grew 123 hemp accessions at three sites in Europe in one season. Genetic components were 74 per cent for the beginning of flowering and 79 per cent for full flowering, with small interactions with site. Most agronomic traits had low genetic components and large interactions. Flowering dates still moved between sites: plants flowered later in the Netherlands and earlier in Italy. The sources support yield, height and total cannabinoid content as more plastic and give no general rule that quantitative characters are. Naim-Feil and colleagues (2023) use "qualitative" for ratios between cannabinoids and "quantitative" for absolute amounts. Faux and colleagues (2014) score sex expression in monoecious hemp on a scale from 0 to 6.
Sources
- Naim-Feil and colleagues (2023), Plants 12: 493: cannabinoid ratios, absolute cannabinoid quantities and broad-sense heritability in clones of 119 genotypes in one controlled-environment facility.
- Petit and colleagues (2020), Frontiers in Plant Science 11: 102: genetic components and interactions with site for 28 traits in 123 hemp accessions at three sites.
Field appearance and genotype
Casañas and colleagues (2017) write on how a landrace is defined. They do not discuss plasticity or what a plant's appearance shows of its genotype, so the lead does not cite them for it. Naim-Feil and colleagues (2023) report traits of inflorescence form as highly affected by growing conditions (mean broad-sense heritability 0.24) in one controlled-environment facility. Petit and colleagues (2020) report low genetic components and large interactions with site for most agronomic traits.
Casañas and colleagues (2017) on landraces
They do not say what part of a landrace's appearance is plastic, and they do not compare the growing conditions of ex situ collections with a landrace's home ground. They mention material held ex situ once, as something local societies should evaluate, and gene banks once, as where landraces gone from cultivation are preserved.