Talk:Lu Thaw
More actions
Discussion for: Lu Thaw • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
Why the area is on the map
- Karen News, 3 July 2013: the secretary of the KNU Mutraw District Organization Department said that villagers hiding from the army in the Pla Ko, Ler Mu Plaw, Kay Pu, Saw Mu Plaw and Na Yo Hta village tracts had begun growing cannabis two years earlier, and that the district had ordered the township official in Lu Thaw to destroy the remaining crop. The same text ran the same day on Burma News International; The Irrawaddy summarised it on 5 July 2013.
- No other report read places cannabis growing in Lu Thaw. The page rests on one statement by one official of the KNU, carried by three outlets, and every cultivation claim in the article is attributed to him or to the KNU.
The village tracts
Karen News spells the tracts Pla Ko, Kay Pu and Na Yo Hta. The Karen Human Rights Group's reports from the township spell what appear to be the same tracts Hpla Hkoh, Hkay Poo and Naw Yo Hta; Ler Mu Plaw and Saw Mu Plaw match in both. Its 2017 update names the five northern tracts: Hkay Poo, Ler Mu Plaw, Saw Mu Plaw, Kaw Loo Der and Naw Yo Hta; and its 2020 update lists Hpla Hkoh among the village tracts of northern Lu Thaw. So four of the five tracts in Karen News lie in the north of the township and the fifth, Pla Ko, is probably Hpla Hkoh. The matching of spellings is an inference from the names and is not stated by either source; the article keeps each source's spelling.
Growing status
The status is Active: the KNU official said the growing began around 2011 and was still going on in 2013. No source gives a later year, and none says that growing has ended. The 2012 and 2013 destruction of the crop does not make the area No longer grown; the 2013 report itself says the KNU could not reach every place where drugs were grown. No first or last year is set, since the status is Active.
The 2012 figures
Karen News says the district destroyed 4,673 plants in 2012, "equal to 4,673 viss", which at its own conversion (one viss, 1.5 kg) would be about 7,000 kg. The Irrawaddy's summary of the same report says "around 7,500 kg of marijuana", and puts a viss at about 1.6 kg. Neither figure is preferred; the article gives both, attributed. One plant to one viss is the source's own equation and is not explained.
How the border is drawn
- Lu Thaw is a KNU township and has no published boundary in any source read. The border is a proxy drawn on the government's Hpapun Township (OpenStreetMap relation 5996622), about 6,700 km², the figure in the infobox. It is the only township of Hpapun District, which the Karen Human Rights Group calls "Hpapun (Mutraw) District".
- The proxy is larger than Lu Thaw. Because it covers the whole of Hpapun District, it also takes in land of the KNU's other two Mutraw townships, Bu Tho and Dwe Lo, where no source read places cannabis growing. A tighter border would need a source for Lu Thaw's own boundary.
- The coordinates are those of Naw Yo Hta village (OpenStreetMap), in one of the five tracts named in Karen News.
- The border is not drawn from accession or news points.
The name
The page takes the form of the township's name that the KNU and the Karen Human Rights Group use, Lu Thaw. Karen News also writes Lu Taw, and some statements from the township write Luthaw. The district is Mutraw (also Mu Traw) in Karen usage and Hpapun in the government's; the article uses Mutraw where the sources speak of the KNU district.
Sources
The Karen News report, its Burma News International copy and The Irrawaddy summary were read in full in copies saved on 19 October 2026. Six Karen Human Rights Group updates from the township (covering January 2013, December 2013, March to May 2014, 2016, December 2016 to January 2017, and January to April 2020) were read for the township's setting and searched for cannabis; none of them mentions it. A March 2018 statement by villagers of the Ler Mu Plaw and Kay Bu tracts on the Salween Peace Park was read and is not used. No later report of cannabis growing in Lu Thaw was found.