Jump to content
Toggle menu
Toggle preferences menu
Toggle personal menu
Not logged in
Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits.
Talk

Discussion for: Hookah • View • Links • Related changes

Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.

Page scope
The page covers the hookah, the water pipe of South Asia, Iran, the Ottoman lands and Egypt, as it has been used for cannabis: its bowl and its names, charas, ganja and hashish mixed into hookah tobacco, the Egyptian goza used for hashish, the question whether the hookah was a cannabis pipe before tobacco, caste and the shared mouthpiece, and the hookah in European images and in later use of the word. Water pipes in general are covered on Water pipes, the clay bowl and pipe of South Asia on Chilam and the Moroccan kif pipe on Sebsi.
Data verification
Record source conflicts, dating problems and unresolved readings here. Keep narrative content on the article.

Discussion

Cannabis in the hookah before tobacco

  • Banglapedia's entry Hooka (Sirajul Islam) states that the hookah was used for cannabis and other narcotics in Bengal before tobacco and was then adapted to tobacco. It cites no source for this.
  • Laufer (1924, pp. 26–27) knew of no document showing that hemp had been smoked from any instrument in Persia or India before tobacco. In 1930 (pp. 14–15) he held that hemp was first smoked in pipes in imitation of tobacco.
  • Gezer (2016, pp. 66–67) states that in the Ottoman lands esrar was only eaten or drunk before tobacco arrived; Khalifa (1975, p. 200) describes the older Egyptian literature as showing hashish eaten.
  • The article gives Islam's statement as his and sets the others beside it.

The date of the Persian water pipe

  • Laufer (1924, pp. 26–27) puts the arrival of tobacco in Persia at the beginning of the 17th century and the first description of the Persian water pipe in Neander's Tabacologia of 1626. Razpush (2000) states that tobacco reached Persia with the Portuguese in the early 16th century and dates the ghalyan to the reign of Tahmasp I from a quatrain of Ahli Shirazi (d. 1535). Elgood's statement that Abu'l-Fath Gilani invented the hookah at Akbar's court is given by Razpush without its source; Razpush concludes that Gilani brought a Persian pipe to India.

Names of the Egyptian pipe

  • Willoughby (1925, p. 375) reports El Guindy's gozah; Soueif (1967; 1971) writes josah; Duvall (2019, p. 19) writes gozeḥ. The article uses goza and gives the source spellings at first mention.

Bernard's painting

  • Duvall (2019, p. 19) names the painting La fumeuse de haschisch (Cairo, 1900). The Musée d'Orsay's catalogue entry, as given on Wikimedia Commons, also lists the title Fumeuse de tombac, a woman smoking tobacco. The article gives Duvall's title and his reading of the picture.

Images reserved in the article

One image has a place in the article but is not yet uploaded:

  • File:Emile-Bernard-La-fumeuse-de-haschisch-Cairo-1900.jpg (lead image): Émile Bernard's painting La fumeuse de haschisch (oil on canvas, Cairo, 1900, Musée d'Orsay), the picture discussed under "The hookah abroad". Wikimedia Commons holds it as "Émile Bernard La fumeuse de Haschisch 1900.jpg", public domain (the painter died in 1941).