Talk:Centre of origin
Discussion page of Centre of origin
More actions
Talk
Discussion for: Centre of origin • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Page scope
Centre of origin covers the idea of a centre of origin of cultivated plants: Vavilov's method and his changing centres, the distinction between centres of origin and centres of diversity, the later schemes of Zhukovsky, Zeven and de Wet, Harlan and others, and where Cannabis has been placed in them. It also covers the separate question of where the genus evolved. The evidence on where and when cannabis was first grown belongs to Domestication; Vavilov's life and expeditions belong to Nikolai Vavilov.
Data verification
Record source conflicts, dating problems and sources not used here. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
Sources
- Vavilov (1926), Центры происхождения культурных растений (Studies on the origin of cultivated plants), Leningrad. The volume carries an English translation on pp. 139–248, from which the article cites: the critique of de Candolle (pp. 143–148), the differential method (pp. 148–152), the mountain regions (pp. 218–220), hemp (pp. 221–233) and the five centres (pp. 241–243).
- Loskutov (1999), Vavilov and his Institute, Rome, International Plant Genetic Resources Institute: the letter of 1923, the five, seven and later centres, "centre" and "focus", dominant and recessive genes, and Zhukovsky's megacentres and microcentres.
- Zeven and de Wet (1982), Dictionary of cultivated plants and their regions of diversity, 2nd edition, Wageningen, Pudoc: Zhukovsky's megacentres, Harlan's centres and non-centres, and the three entries for Cannabis sativa (pp. 33, 71 and 149).
- Maxted and Vincent (2021), Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution 68: 1283–1297: the history of the schemes, the comparison with crop wild relative hotspots, and the amended table of Vavilov's centres.
- Khoury and colleagues (2016), Proceedings of the Royal Society B 283: 20160792; Hummer and Hancock (2015), HortScience 50: 780–783; Larson and colleagues (2014), PNAS 111: 6139–6146: centres of diversity and the number of independent origins of agriculture.
- McPartland (2018), Cannabis and Cannabinoid Research 3: 203–212; McPartland, Hegman and Long (2019), Vegetation History and Archaeobotany 28: 691–702 (read in its published abstract); Kovalchuk and colleagues (2020), Annual Review of Plant Biology 71: 713–739; Balant and colleagues (2025), Plants, People, Planet 7: 1771–1788: where the genus arose.
- Ren and colleagues (2021), Science Advances 7: eabg2286; McPartland and Small (2020), PhytoKeys 144: 81–112: the domestication question, Vavilov's two centres for C. indica and the landraces in their centres of diversity.
- Not used, because no open copy could be read: Harlan, "Agricultural origins: centers and noncenters" (Science, 1971) and Crops and Man (1975, 1992); Hawkes, The Diversity of Crop Plants (1983); Vavilov's English collections of 1951 and 1992; Zeven and Zhukovsky's first edition of 1975; Hillig, "Genetic evidence for speciation in Cannabis" (2005); Clarke and Merlin, Cannabis: Evolution and Ethnobotany (2013). Harlan's and Zhukovsky's schemes are reported here from Zeven and de Wet, Maxted and Vincent, and Loskutov.
Source discrepancies
- When Vavilov first named centres. Hummer and Hancock (2015) write that Vavilov proposed five centres in 1924. Loskutov (1999) dates his paper on the eastern centres to 1924 and his first summary of five major foci to 1926; the five centres in the article are those of the 1926 book.
- Who used "microcentres". Loskutov (1999) credits Zhukovsky with "microcentres", small foci where narrowly distributed endemic species were taken into cultivation. Zeven and de Wet (1982) use "gene microcentres" for small areas of rapid evolution that Harlan described in Turkey in 1951.
- Zhukovsky's twelve areas. Zeven and de Wet write that the North American area had been proposed by Darlington and Janaki Ammal (1945) and the European one by Darlington (1956) before Zhukovsky included them. Loskutov reports that Zhukovsky in 1970 proposed four centres, the Euro-Siberian, African, Australian and North American, to be added to Vavilov's seven.
- Hemp in the later dictionaries. Zeven and de Wet place the centre of origin of C. sativa in Central Asia under the Hindustani region, list the crop under three regions, and write under the European–Siberian region that it had reached China by 2500 BC. The amended table of Maxted and Vincent lists only subsp. indica, under the Central Asian centre.
- Two pollen syntheses. McPartland (2018) reports a meta-analysis of 88 fossil pollen studies in Asia; McPartland, Hegman and Long (2019) report 155. Both place the centre of origin of the genus on the north-eastern Tibetan Plateau.
Terms
- A centre of origin in Vavilov's sense is the area where the forms of a crop arose; a centre of diversity is the area where its varieties, races and wild relatives are now most varied. Vavilov took the second as the usual guide to the first.
- Megacentre (Zhukovsky, 1968) and region (Zeven and de Wet, 1982) name the same twelve large areas.
- A non-centre (Harlan, 1971) is a large area over which crop domestication spread from a centre and went on in many places.
Images
- File:Vavilov-centres-of-origin-map.jpg (lead, in the series box). An outline map of the world with the eight centres of 1935 shaded black and the Indo-Malayan, Chiloé and Brazil–Paraguay sub-centres. The map numbers the centres from west to east, not in Vavilov's own order.
- File:Nikolai-Vavilov-portrait-1933-NYWTS.jpg (Vavilov's method).
- File:Vavilov Gui-Akhen neotype, McPartland and Small 2020 fig 5a.jpg (Vavilov on hemp). A plant grown in Russia in 1926 from seed collected at Gui-Akhen, Afghanistan, in 1924.