Talk:Cannabis prohibition
Discussion page of Cannabis prohibition
More actions
Talk
Discussion for: Cannabis prohibition • View • Links • Related changes
Use this page for verification notes, disputes, and action items. Keep narrative content on the article.
Page scope
Cannabis prohibition covers the ban on cannabis as a drug in national law and in the international treaties: the parts of the plant and the purposes the laws reach, the 19th-century choice between licensing and banning, the Geneva convention of 1925 and the national bans that followed, the Single Convention of 1961 and the conventions of 1971 and 1988, eradication, the decriminalisation and legal markets of recent decades, and the effects of prohibition on landraces, seed collections and traditional growers. Each treaty, country and campaign has its own page, linked from the section that summarises it.
Data verification
Record source conflicts, dating problems and unresolved readings here. Keep narrative content on the article.
Discussion
The date of Egypt's first ban
- The Transnational Institute (Bewley-Taylor, Blickman and Jelsma 2014, p. 5) lists a ban on the cultivation, use and import of cannabis in 1868, under Ottoman rule, followed by measures of 1874, 1877, 1879 and 1884.
- El Hadka (1965) dates a law against cultivation to 1879; Soueif (1967) surveys the legislation "on record since 1879"; Khalifa (1975, p. 199) traces attempts to legislate back to 1879.
- El Guindy, addressing the Geneva conference in December 1924, gave 1884 as the year cultivation was forbidden (League of Nations, Records, vol. I, p. 133).
- The three dates come from different kinds of witness: a later institute's survey, two Egyptian authors writing in the 1960s and 1970s, and Egypt's own delegate in 1924. The same dispute is set out on Egypt.
The date of the Greek ban
- Stefanis, Ballas and Madianou (1975, p. 314) date to 27 March 1890 a circular of the Department of the Interior prohibiting the import, cultivation and use of hashish, "in force until 1920". Bouquet (1951) dates the ban on cultivation to 1920. Greek hashish trade follows the law of 1920 (Law 2107/1920). The 1890 circular and the 1920 law are two measures, not two datings of one.
Mauritius, 1840–1854
- The ordinance of 2 March 1840 banned the import, sale and growing of cannabis, and an ordinance of 1854 repealed the ban on import (A Collection of the Laws of Mauritius, vol. 4). Banks (2021) writes of "some forty years of prohibition" introduced under the 1840 ordinance. The two fit if the bans on sale and growing outlasted the import ban; the date of their repeal would decide it.
El Guindy's figures
- El Guindy told the conference that hashish caused "from 30 to 60 per cent" of the cases of insanity in Egypt (Records, vol. I, p. 134). Bewley-Taylor, Blickman and Jelsma (2014, p. 11) set against it the 1920–21 report of the Abbasiya asylum in Cairo, which attributed 19 of 715 admissions (2.7 per cent) to hashish.
Eradication and genetic diversity
- The figure of more than 1.9 billion feral plants destroyed in the United States from 1998 to 2006 (Canavan et al. 2022) counts plants. Aina et al. (2025) sampled feral populations across the country and found five genetic clusters. Neither study measures the diversity the populations held before eradication.
- For the Rif, Chouvy and Afsahi (2014) state that the role of forced eradication in the turn to hybrids is unclear, because most eradication took place outside the historic growing zone. Their statement concerns one region.
Motives for the early bans
- Each motive is one author's reading of particular cases: Duvall (2019) for French Congo and Ottoman Egypt, Bonnie and Whitebread (1970) for the western American states, Rubin and Comitas (1975) for Jamaica and Kozma (2011) for Egypt. None of the four offers a general explanation of prohibition.